Editorial Review
16 December 2005
"What are the chances
of the Arab Nation wrestling control of its destiny from the three
main powers locking horns in the region to usurp the wealth and
future of the Arab World: The Arab dictatorial regimes, Bush's
America and the militants"?
"Never been greater in the past 100 years," A. S. Bishtawi, author
of History of Injustice in the Arab world, said in answer to
journalists during the launch of his new book at the Sharjah
International Book fair. "Through his totally unexpected moral,
political and military failure in Iraq, US President George W. Bush
did not just fail to uphold the high moral standards of the founding
fathers of the United States of America but also all Arab
dictatorial rulers who betted on a quick victory and provided him
with all the support they could muster despite the opposition of the
populace to the invasion and occupation of Iraq", he said.
"Instead of forcing Iraqis to give him a free hand in moulding Iraq
as the hearts of the Likud and the Neo-Cons desired, his endless
misjudgements and considerable losses suffered in that Arab country
in the past 20 months freed Iraqis of their fear of the might of the
US", Bishtawi said. "Soon afterwards other Arabs were liberated by
the Iraqis of their fear of the US and subsequently of their fear of
Arab dictators who have been tormenting them for the last 60 years
with considerable help and support from the West, particularly the
US."
"These dictators are the Berlin Wall of the Arab World", Bishtawi
said. "And like the German wall, they will come crashing down
because the pillars of US foreign policy that provided them with
support since the mid-1950s came crashing down in Iraq. President
Bush may recover his sagging popularity at home; he may have to pay
the price for causing the death of 100,000 innocent Iraqis but then
again he may not. The greatest price of his failure will be paid by
the Arab dictators who opened their borders to the invading armies
of the US and Great Britain to wreak havoc in another Arab and
Muslim country. That price is likely to be their extinction within
the next 5 years".
"The removal of US troops occupying Iraq will accelerate the already
fading US influence in the region", Bishtawi believes. "One
significant development was the easy removal last August of
Mauritanian president Moawiah Wild Al Taia, Bush's most loyal petty
dictator in the Middle East, and the subsequent failure of the US
Administration to reinstate him".
"President Bush's other great friend, the Egyptian President Hosni
Mubarak, has demonstrated during the November/December parliamentary
elections the type of brutality not seen in Egypt since the early
1950s by the then occupation forces of Great Britain. Government
thugs armed with swords and daggers attacked democracy activists and
thousands of police in full riot gear prevented voters from casting
their ballots. If the World had any doubts that Mubarak is running a
police state, the shocking violence in Alexandria and several other
major cities worked to dispel them".
Bishtawi explained that the brutality of Mubarak's thugs may have
succeeded in silencing the opposition had it not been for the almost
miraculous ability of Iraqis, and later other Arabs, to liberate
themselves from fear.
"Chapter 8 is largely dedicated to dissect the fear factor in the
Arab World", Bishtawi said. "It is fear that Arab regimes have used
extensively to subdue the populace, and it is fear President Bush
employed excessively to try to subdue Iraq. More fear and desperate
acts of state terrorism may be used in the near future as a last
resort to remain in power".
"There is a psychological fact of vital importance Arabs must pay
attention to: A frightened government is incapable of frightening
its people. Arabs after 30 months of the sole superpower engaged in
a futile attempt to pacify a devastated Iraq are neither afraid of
the US nor of Israel and their own governments. The opposite may be
argued to be true. This is one reason why Egyptians say the
situation will never be the same in the country. Almost suddenly
they realize Mubarak is fighting for his very survival and that of
his ruling clan and there is no power on earth that can instil the
same fear in a liberated heart."
"We were conned by President Bush into believing he wants democracy
in the Middle East but we know now he is interested in Israel and
oil. Any Middle East country that proves useful in safeguarding
these two most important pillars of US foreign policy in the region
are friends of the US and are immune."
"Not very long ago he talked about Iraq becoming a beacon of
democracy and human rights in the Arab World", Bishtawi said.
"Thirty months of occupation have changed all that. US- occupied
Iraq is an exporter of terrorism to other Arab countries, and the
CIA is exporting torture to several countries in the Middle East."
On page 16 the author writes: "American foreign policy sided with
Arab dictatorial regimes against the interests of the nation so the
regimes sided with the US against the interests of the people they
rule. But the nation is regaining its will to deal with these
interests. Therefore there is no connection between what is
happening in Iraq, Lebanon, Syria, Egypt and Palestine unless we
read in all of this the outcome of the Arabs' liberation of their
fear of the US. Once that was achieved, the old fear of brutal
regimes has all but dissipated."
The eventual removal of both the dictatorial regimes and US troops
from Iraq is bound to deprive the majority of militants of their
cause and further popular support. Many claim they are rising
against both Arab and western injustice that lasted almost 100 years
but the removal of foreign troops and Arab dictators will remove the
major cause of the injustice. The hardened few can be easily dealt
with.
"At the end justice will be done", the author writes," but justice
is more often taken than given away. There is nothing without value,
aim or price. To expel fear from their world, Arabs must first expel
fear from themselves. To see light, they have to open their eyes. To
march into the age of freedom, they have to leave the caves of
emotion and militancy that reside in their minds. To recover their
lost land, rights, dignity, security and prosperity, and to keep all
these for themselves and their offspring until God inherits the
Earth, they have to devise new strategies that suit our age and
discard old beliefs that have exasperated the theft of their lands,
rights and dignity, weakened their economy and spread injustice.
Unless they do all this, Arabs will not take the correct decision
and the thugs who confiscated their ability and right to make
decisions will confiscate their right to make the decisions once
more. A new era of injustice, both Arab and Western, will commence
and only God knows when will it end."
The writer concedes the challenges ahead are difficult and many but
he has no doubt that Arabs will be able to build a superpower in the
next 15-20 years. This can be achieved, he says, peacefully. "Blood
spilled for freedom is no longer required in this age and
dictatorial governments will suffocate by the clean air of the
correct democracy heaving with hearts that had enough of Arab and
Western oppression."
But there is also a warning: "Arabs must beware of claims by their
regimes that the West is their eternal enemy and they are their
eternal friend. These regimes will spread this falsehood to continue
their oppression...And Arabs should remember that without the help
of Arab and Western governments, Iraq's dictator Saddam Hussein
would not have been able to persecute Iraq for so long, nor would
Bush have been able to occupy Iraq. And without the terrorism of
these regimes, some Arabs would not have known terrorism and Bush
would not have come to the Arab home an invader and occupier to win
the greatest prize of all: Oil. Both are one and the same, and both
are afraid but Arabs should beware of sacrificing the persecuted
Iraq at the alter of their hatred for Bush. They should help Iraq
emerge from its crisis because the entire nation will emerge with it
from its crisis".
"The options before the nation today are not between the evil and
the lesser evil; not between those who want the likes of Saddam and
those who want Bush, nor between Bush's values and injustice, or
between a dormant development and backwardness. There are no real
options in such vile alternatives because they will ensure the
continuation of the old injustice, occupation, misery,
underdevelopment but in a fresh wrapping".
"Those who study the state of the nation will realize that the home
of the largest wealth the World has ever known is home to poverty
unknown in the jungles of Africa and mountains of Spanish America.
And those who study the state of the nation will realize that the
real development can not wait long years because the new generation
is growing impatient. Tens of millions of young men and women are
growing restless and they believe there are no real alternatives but
confrontation. The new generation is the future and it is up to
American and European leaders to decide what sort of future they
will choose".
"Not all who criticize American foreign policy are terrorists, and
not all who criticize Israel are anti-Semitic and not all who
criticize Arab regimes are CIA agents but we are in the age of fear
and smear, and logic has no meaning. It is therefore conceivable
that all those who criticize Bush are treated as terrorists or
"enemy combatants", and those who criticize Israel are branded as
anti-Semitic, and those who dare criticize Arab governments are
smeared as CIA agents."
To study the state of the nation is to conclude that the hearts of
most of its sons and daughters are with the Arab and Muslim Iraq but
the hearts of most Arab dictators are with Bush. The fear of Bush
and the fear of Arab dictators is one and the same - for Iraq to
emerge victorious and for the occupation to end in defeat, for
democracy to advance and injustice to retreat, for people to regain
their destiny and dignity or for the regimes and their protector in
Washington to keep the nation weak and humiliated."
"Like the their ancestors on the eve of the fall of Acre in 1291,"
Bishtawi concluded, "Arabs today have a choice but the ability to
make a choice is not enough - it must be the correct one." |